Skip to Content
Top
What Happens If Both Drivers are at Fault in a Car Accident in Texas?

What Happens If Both Drivers are at Fault?

Texas Modified Comparative Negligence Rules for Car Accidents

Often, it is really easy to pin the blame on one driver after a car accident and expect them to be fully liable for the damages. In truth, though, many car accidents are caused by both drivers making different mistakes that contributed to the crash. What happens then?

In Texas, liability for auto accidents is examined using a modified comparative negligence rule. This system allows liability to be assigned to each driver based on the mistakes they made and how that affected the chances of the accident occurring and the severity of everyone’s injuries. For example, if there was a five-car crash and every driver was equally negligent, i.e., liable, then each driver would have 20% liability assigned to them.

However, the “modified” part of Texas’s modified comparative negligence rule means that a driver can lose the opportunity to file a claim against another party if they are found to be mostly liable for the accident. Any driver who is at least 51% liable for a car accident cannot recover damages from the other parties involved. Under this system, it is imperative that claimants can argue down their liability as much as possible, which is usually handled best by a car accident attorney.

Modified Comparative Negligence in a Two-Car Accident

Imagine that you were in a car accident with just one other driver in Texas. You admit that you were reading and distracted by a billboard on the side of the road when the crash happened. But criminal evidence shows that the other driver was drunk and speeding at the time.

The liability in this situation may be split 80-20 in your favor, meaning the drunk driver is determined to be 80% at fault for the crash. Any apportionment is determined by a jury. With this liability assignment, the other driver cannot demand damages from you or your insurance company at all. But you can still hold them accountable for 80% of your damages, which is your damages minus the amount for which you are liable (20%). This scenario shows the benefit of a modified comparative negligence system because it disallows counter-lawsuits that would only slow down your claim and possibly cost you money as you attempt to defend yourself.

Consider Buying PIP Insurance

Even the best drivers can make serious mistakes sometimes and cause an accident. If this happens to you, then you could be in serious financial trouble if you’re found to be at least 51% liable for the crash. To safeguard your finances against such a situation, it is advised that you talk to your auto insurance provider about adding personal injury protection (PIP) insurance to your policy. PIP insurance pays for certain damages without considering liability, which means you can get much-needed coverage even if Texas’s modified comparative negligence rules prevent you from suing the other driver.

Damages that can be covered with PIP insurance include:

  • Medical bills
  • Lost income
  • Aftercare requirements
  • And more

PIP insurance also does not preclude you from filing a claim against another driver if you are able. You can use your PIP coverage to get benefits right away while still suing another driver, assuming your liability remains below the 51% threshold.

In a Multicar Crash? Call Scott Law Firm

Our car accident attorneys from Scott Law Firm have seen pretty much every imaginable car accident claim since we first opened our doors in Conroe, Texas. If you were in a multicar collision and don’t know who to file a claim against because you might be partially liable, then we can help you sort everything out. Leave the details of your case up to us while you focus on recovering.

Contact us online or call (936) 243-4299 to request a no-cost, confidential consultation.

Client TEStimonials

At Scott Law Firm, your satisfaction is our priority! See for yourself what our clients have to say about working with us.

    “They Truly Cared”
    From the very beginning, they were professional, responsive, and truly cared about my case. They took the time to explain everything clearly, kept me updated throughout the process, and made sure I always felt supported and informed.

    I can’t recommend Mr. Scott and his team highly enough. From the very beginning, they were professional, responsive, and truly cared about my case. I would especially like to thank Ms. Conchita and Mimi, who took the time to explain everything clearly, kept me updated throughout the process, and made sure I always felt supported and informed. Navigating an injury claim can be overwhelming, but they made it as stress-free as possible and fought hard on my behalf. I’m extremely grateful for their dedication and would absolutely recommend them to anyone needing an injury attorney.

    - Former Client
    “Compassion and Genuine Care”
    The Scott Law Firm team demonstrated professionalism, compassion, and genuine care throughout the experience. The support was efficient, thoughtful, and met my expectations. Thank you!

    I am very satisfied with the service provided. The Scott law firm team demonstrated professionalism, compassion, and genuine care throughout the experience. The support was efficient, thoughtful, and met my expectations. I would confidently recommend their services to others. Thank you Scott Law firm.

    - Former Client
    “Go See These People”
    They FOUGHT for me! The love they have for their clients is next to none I’ve ever experienced before. The customer service, the professionalism, the personal care; the way everyone makes you feel you’re the only one that matters.

    Go see these people!!! I was injured on the job in January of this year pretty significantly. When I was able to return home after a long stay at the hospital and inpatient rehab, I started to think about what the future was going to look like. As everyone knows, workers comp is not the easiest thing to live with or even deal with. Luckily, workers comp hasn’t been an issue of mine. But what was an issue was the future. I’m employed full time at one place and part time at another. My part time job was one to “fluff” the bank account for extra expenses and taxes at the end of the year. Over time with the injury, I lost that job due to a technicality and wasn’t able to work anyhow. So I started calling law firms in the area. Big ones, small ones. I talked to 12 of them. The very first one that reached out was Scott Law Firm right down the road from the house. All the other law firms had told me I “had no case,” as it was indeed a complicated case. Eleven “no’s” I received. Pretty discouraging. Except that one little law firm in Conroe. When I went to the office for the initial meeting after a phone conversation, I was greeted by nothing but smiles as well as compassion for the time I’ve been experiencing while dealing with doctors, PT appointments and surgeries. They told me, “let’s take a look at what we can do.” I met with Lisett and Mr. Scott for over an hour as Mr. Scott explained what he did, where he looks, etc. to find his clients money in these injury claims. When I tell you they left no leaf unturned, they did EVERYTHING in their power to get me at least SOMETHING to cover that little bit that workers comp wasn’t able to cover. A few months later, a few phone calls, I had mentioned one little surgery. A card showed up in my mailbox 4 days later. If that doesn’t show you respect and compassion… idk what will. The professionalism, the emails, the phone calls, the way they make you feel welcomed and cared for is like none I’ve ever experienced before. They paid me out twice with what they were able to get. They FOUGHT for me. They got me much more than I was ever expecting. When I left their new office just now, they have a big bell hanging on the wall with a sign that reads “Mission Accomplished.” I rang that bell and we cheered. All smiles, clapping and hugs. But in the background, upstairs, around the corners, in other offices down the halls came cheering. Clappers. Bells. The entire office came to the foyer to cheer and celebrate with me. The love they have for their clients is next to no one I’ve ever experienced before. The customer service, the professionalism, the personal care; the way everyone makes you feel you’re the only one that matters. Thank you Patrick, Lisett, Daniela, Conchita, everyone for turning the most terrible situation in my life into a positive experience. Thank you Scott Law Firm.

    - Former Client
    “Client Oriented & Personal”
    Scott Law Firm is super helpful! They will take their time to explain things to you and address any concerns you may have. Very client-oriented and personal.

    Scott Law Firm is super helpful! They will take their time to explain things to you and address any concerns you may have. Very client-oriented and personal.

    - Corey S.
    “They Treated Us Like Family”
    My case was small but they acted as if was the only case they had. They spent a lot of time explaining the process and what to expect. They were proactive and responded to our concerns quickly, keeping us informed.

    I found everyone at Scott Law Firm to be interested, concerned, and by my side during the whole process of my case. My case was small but they acted as if was the only case they had. Scott spent a lot of time explaining how the process works, what they would do, and what to expect. His people were pro-active, they responded to our concerns quickly, keeping us informed, and in the end they exceeded all of our expectations. They treated us like family.

    - John K.
    “Personal Care & Professional Excellence”
    I want to thank the entire staff at Scott Law Firm for their personal care and professional excellence. I want to thank God for putting me in the hands of Mr. Scott and his very capable staff. The outcome of my case was very fair.

    I want to thank Mr. Patrick Scott and the entire staff at Scott Law Firm for the personal care and professional excellence they demonstrated to my husband and me and my injury case. My life work as a registered nurse has given me various opportunities to help and care for others in a meaningful way. However, to find myself in need of care and a diligent advocate was very new to me. I want to thank God for putting me in the hands of Mr. Scott and his very capable staff. The outcome of my case was very fair. I would highly recommend the Scott Law Firm without hesitation.

    - Nora G.
  • Committed to Delivering Quality Representation to the Conroe Community
  • Free Consultations and No Fees Unless We Win
  • Team of Knowledgeable Attorneys Who Focus on Your Case, So You Can Focus on Your Recovery
  • Focused & Dedicated Attention Tailored to Your Unique Needs and Situation